The IT maturity can be seen as an issue of matching services offered by IT with the requirements of the business. In businesses of any significant size, IT maturity and alignment of IT with business is a hard problem that currently is not completely solved. With the advent of cross-organizational collaborations, the problem gets a new dimension because in cross-organizational settings there is usually no single decision point. Various maturity levels can be identified for the alignment between business and IT. Therefore, maturity models seem to be a suitable vehicle for deeper understanding and assessment of IT maturity within companies. In order to assess current status of IT maturity in BIH companies a crosscutting overview of two commonly used IT/IS models has been used in our research – Nolan’s stage model and IT value-perception model.
In 1979, Richard L. Nolan developed, and in 1995, he updated his six stages IT Evolution/Maturing Model (Nolan and Croson, 1995) as one of the earliest models/frameworks of the information system stage development, meaning the evolution of information technologies within companies. Nolan is of an opinion that the companies, instead of trying to make a single large stride forward when it comes to the implementation of IT within their operations, should think of IT evolution as a sequential process. He proposes six stages that this evolution should be taking place through. These six stages are, according to Nolan, divided in two eras: the Data Processing Era ((i) Initiation, (ii) Expansion and (iii) Control) and the IT Era ((iv) Integration, (v) Data administration and (vi) Maturity) separated by the technology transformation gap/discontinuity.
It was due to the shortcomings of Nolan’s model, especially the lack of an empirical proof of the model itself, that Winggers, Kok and De Boor – de Wit (2004) defined the new model of the IT evolution within the company named the “IT value perception” model. The authors of this model defined the correlation between the maturity of demands on the X-axis and the maturity of supply on the Y-axis, and presented the IT transformation in the company within four stages: (i) IT as facilitator, (ii) IT as service, (iii) IT as partner, and (iv) IT as enabler.
In order to better understand and analyze the IT maturity in BiH companies, a research was conducted on basic characteristics and current state of IT and information systems. Methodology-vise, this research presents a quantitative research of the IT maturity of the companies themselves and the method used is an opinion poll conducted on a target group of professionals. A questionnaire was sent to 120 BH companies, while 40 of them participated in a very research, which represents 30% response rate.
The usual perception of BH businesses as being quite traditionally organized and without usage of modern information technologies simply does not fit into factual data received through research. Of course, one must be skeptical regarding some of the answers and statistics related to that. For example, 68,6% of companies claimed to have integrated IT systems. It is quite questionable does the term “integrated IT system” has the same meaning for all respondents. Truly integrated IT systems are generally not so easy to find and it is hard to believe that two thirds of BH companies are having such situation.
On the other hand some of the answers clearly position most of the companies into more mature stages of both models used. The fact that 88,5% companies responded that they cannot function without IT, that 97,1% companies consider IT responsible for their increased efficiency and considers IT to be their competitive advantage, the fact that 74,3% of companies are taking the information technologies into account within their strategic planning and that 51,4% of companies are having their CIO positioned to companies’ top management has shown that there is a clear understanding of the strategic importance of the information technologies and its enabling role for their businesses. It means that majority of companies that responded to research are in IT era in Nolan model’s sense, and are perceiving the IT as partner and enabler for their core businesses, in “IT value perception” model’s sense.